Editor Rev. Andrew Kuyvenhoven, 1980-1989

Written on 11/16/2026
Gayla R. Postma

Note: This online-only article is part of a series showcasing past Banner editors. You can read all the content celebrating The Banner’s 160th anniversary here.

Rev. Andrew Kuyvenhoven was appointed as editor of The Banner in 1980. He was the first Dutch Canadian to hold that position.

But his Dutch roots did not stop him from making a big splash early on when he published The Banner cover showing a pair of wooden shoes up in flames.

“A pair of burning wooden shoes! It is probably the most famous—or infamous—cover of the Christian Reformed Church’s magazine, The Banner.” That’s what David Zwart wrote in 2014 in the Reformed Journal. “The cover and the content of that edition made it clear it was time for the CRC to move beyond its Dutch heritage.”

Herbert Brinks wrote in The Banner in 1991, “Andy Kuyvenhoven famously drew a line between the CRC’s ethnic and Reformed roots. The resulting controversy burned as brightly as the flames enveloping the wooden shoes on the cover.” One reader wrote to Kuyvenhoven suggesting he burn The Banner instead. Another reader, according to Brinks, stopped by the Banner office to present a brand-new pair to the editor.

Kuyvenhoven’s arrival brought many changes to the magazine internally. He brought on new staff, including an assistant who soon became the news editor. Staff became more involved in evaluating copy and discussing Banner theme issues

His tenure brought a new network of 12 news writers from across the U.S. and Canada, of which this writer was one. That network remains to this day, providing news from local churches and regions to the readers of The Banner. The news pages are still among the most-read sections of The Banner, according to reader surveys.

The production schedule was changed to allow insertion of late news items. New columns and new columnists were introduced. A report to Synod 1981 reported that most Banner readers liked the changes. Subscription rates steadily climbed.

Each month one issue was devoted to a specific theme. Theme issues on women in ecclesiastical office and another on homosexuality elicited ferocious discussion, much of the correspondence vociferously expressing consternation at positions taken by the editor or by the writer of an article.

Writing about editors she has known, Gertrude Haan wrote in The Banner, “If there is one thing that will characterize the new editor, he will not be unduly concerned whether he is labeled either conservative or liberal. His great concern is rather to be biblical—true to the word of God, wherever it may lead him. His penetrating insights into the Reformed faith and his wide knowledge of theology and the church scene are already known among his colleagues in the ministry and the congregations he has served. His deep pastoral concern for the church is combined with the native understanding of what the people need and want.”

That opinion was affirmed when Kuyvenhoven received the alumni award from Calvin Theological Seminary. The citation noted that as Banner editor, his “church” became the hearts and minds of thousands of additional congregants.

In addition to his roles as pastor and editor, Kuyvenhoven was theological editor for what was then the CRC’s Board of Publications and author of several books, study guides, and devotionals.

In Kuyvenhoven’s memoriam in The Banner, his son Leonard noted that his father pastorally and even-handedly led the church in discussions of pertinent issues. “And he could do it (mostly) while retaining a sense of humor,” Leonard said. “He loved the gospel, and he loved the church.”